新JJ,语法题！

lilya

SC: A company distributed many computers to many students (to be in place of ) books.
to be placement of; for them to replace; for them to in place of; for them to placement of;

I prefer B: to be placement of

spark

maybe A is better?

cythay

我觉得还是 "for them to replace"比较好的

sherry

支持for them to replace

能用v.则不用replacement
in place of一般用来表示名词，如 n.in place of n. 或 n.is used in place of n.
表示动作一般用replace
另外我感觉them在此没有歧义
而many students (to be in place of ) books.感觉上像students replace books, 而不是computers replace books.

大家认为呢？

[此贴子已经被作者于2003-2-17 21:58:11编辑过]

12345

支持a

kurt

A，目的状语
B，TO BE + 名词，错误
C，FOR THEM 指代不清

kurt

TO BE + NOUN 肯定不对
FOR THEM 指代不清
大致A好

kurt

TO BE + NOUN 肯定不对
FOR THEM 指代不清
大致A好

天下无双

我查了字典（金山和韦氏），现将韦氏的解释摘录如下：
Main Entry:placement
Pronunciation:*pl*s-m*nt
Function:noun
Date:1844

1 : an act or instance of placing: as  a : an accurately hit ball (as in tennis) that an opponent cannot return  b : the assignment of a person to a suitable place (as a job or a class in school)
2 : PLACEKICK
金山上面也没有说placement有动词的意思。
所以我觉得用placment不大妥当，大家一起来讨论。

yuw99gmat

我觉得for them to replace; for them to in place of; for them to placement of;
都好像不对，them,指代混乱
但是，to be placement of 更不对，也不好，

但是如果没有更好的选择，我还是choose " for them to replace "