as well as 和 and 求助~

Stefaniezhu

是不是很多情况下as well as 和 and 不可以替换啊？否则是改变句意？

myungryong

受教
A and B, as well as C

Karmalotse

首先 both A and B, as well as C  应该是没有问题的

其次 both A, as well as B
查了一下，有很多说是不可以的
"Both Jack as well as Jill" is completely wrong. Either eliminate "both" or use "and" instead of "as well as."

但是还是有很多这么用的，不过这种有争议的东西，还是不用比较好
the construction both X as well as Y (for any phrases X and Y), though common in unplanned speech, is not syntactically well formed. Particularly not when X is a plain-form (bare infinitive) verb phrase and Y is a gerund-participial verb phrase. That is (to invent a shorter case of the same sort), *to both survive as well as flourishing seems to me like an error of sentence planning, where what was intended was to both survive and flourish.

Stefaniezhu

both ... as well as吗？不是在做题中这个可以用来排除吗？

Karmalotse

除了楼上说的，还有一些

刚好也在看贴上来：

有时 as well as 所连成分并未有侧重，这时相当于and 但是和and又有三点不同
（1）as well as 含有 “又”的意思。这种情况多用于as well as 前后是形容词或副词
The plan is practical as well as far-sighted
She is clever as well as beautiful
（2）and 可以用于 A,B, and c    /   as well as 用于 A and B as well as C
比如 we study physics and chemistry as well as mathematics.
（3）有时候可以用both… as well as
This collection of stories includes both foreign as well as Chinese works.

myungryong

A and B : A 和 B同等重要
A as well as B: A 比 B 重要