搞不清楚这道题的逻辑~求助呀~~~

sunzehua700

Citizensof Parktown are worried by the increased frequency of serious crimes committedby local teenagers.  In response, thecity government has instituted a series of measures designed to keep teenagersat home in the late evening.  Even if themeasures succeed in keeping teenagers at home, however, they are unlikely toaffect the problem that concerns citizens, since most crimes committed by localteenagers take place between 3 p.m. and 6 p.m.
Whichof the following, if true, most substantially weakens the argument?
A.Similar measures adopted in other places have failed to reduce the number ofteenagers on the streets in the late evening.
B.The crimes committed by teenagers in the afternoon are mostly small thefts andinconsequential vandalism.
C.Teenagers are much less likely to commit serious crimes when they are at homethan when they are not at home.
D.Any decrease in the need for police patrols in the late evening would not meanthat there could be more intensive patrolling in the afternoon.
E.The schools in Parktown have introduced a number of after-school programs thatwill be available to teenagers until 6 p.m. on weekday afternoons.




我选得E。。但是答案居然给的是B。。实在觉得B是不相关信息啊。。求助各位，到底应该选哪个？？

momohe

Problem is that city people are concerned with the increase of frequency in seriouscrimes. The word serious is the key here.

Conclusion is that the measure to keep children after 6 pm/ late evening will not help because most crime happens between 3 and 6

We have to prove that measures will be effective. What if the crimes that happen between 3 and 6 are petty and inconsequential? Not serious any more?? measures are effective. Hence B

To me A,C, D are out of scope. E makes an attempt but because E does not tell us whether the teens will stay in school. An assumption needs to be made to weaken the conclusion. Hence B is better。

huangsiyan

i think B is right. It said"The crimes committed by teenagers in the afternoon are mostly small thefts and inconsequential vandalism". Thus, the crimes committed by teenagers in the afternoon are so insignificant that citizens won't be concerned about them.

SO, B can weaken the argument that" they are unlikely to affect the problem that concerns citizens, since most crimes committed by local teenagers take place between 3 p.m. and 6 p.m."