返回列表 发帖

一道unless题

A package is never accepted for delivery by the delivery service unless it is within the established size limits. All packages accepted for delivery by delivery service have a return address.

If the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true?

A  The delivery service charges more for heavier packages that for lighter packages.

B The delivery service will always accept for delivery a package that is within the established size limits.

C If a package is within the established size limits and has a return address, it will be accepted for delivery by the delivery service no matter how heavy the package is.

D A package that is not within the established size limits but has a return address is never accepted for delivery by the delivery service.

E The delivery service does not charge for package that must be returned to the sender.

答案是D. 我选了B.因为这个就是文中的逆否啊.......

收藏 分享

我觉得文中的逆否应当是:若包裹被接受了,包裹一定符合大小限制。
但是B的表达是说,只要包裹符合了大小限制就一定会被接受。这两个表达是不一样的。

TOP

貌似:

原句意思within the size 是deliver的充分条件

B变成了within the size是deliver 的必要条件

TOP

A package is never accepted for delivery by the delivery service unless it is within the established size limits.

     Conclusion A.    if not S(size Ok), not A(accept)=〉[ if A, then S]

All packages accepted for delivery by delivery service have a return address.

     Conclusion B.    if A, then R(have return address)

Choice B The delivery service will always accept for delivery a package that is within the established size limits

                  =[ If S, then A]  

Choice D [if (not S)&R, then not S. ------If not S, then not A]

TOP

b当中 within the size就是充分条件吧,ls?

TOP

B明显不对:题干:接受邮包推出邮包SIME对,B将之反过来是推不出来的。

TOP

返回列表

站长推荐 关闭


美国top10 MBA VIP申请服务

自2003年开始提供 MBA 申请服务以来,保持着90% 以上的成功率,其中Top10 MBA服务成功率更是高达95%


查看