OG11-92：一道必须比较完全部选项才能选的逻辑题

tomchengs

OG11-92 In order to finance road repairs, the highway commission of a certain state is considering a 50 percent increase in the 10-cents-per-mile toll for vehicles using its toll highway. The highway commissioner claims that the toll increase will increase the annual revenue generated by the toll highway by at least 50 percent per year.

Which of the following is an assumption on which the highway commissioner's claim depends?

(A) The amount of money required annually for road repairs will not increase from its current level.
(B) The total number of trips made on the toll highway per year will not decrease from its current level.
(C) The average length of a trip made on the toll highway will not decrease from its current level.
(D) The number of drivers who consistently avoid the highway tolls by using secondary roads will not increase from its current level.
(E) The total distance traveled by vehicles on the toll highway per year will not decrease from its current level. Argument Construction
E
感想：total distance=total number *The average length
所以其它几个选项其实也并非完全错，只是E更全面而已
而我个人觉得在同类题型中，其它题目好像并没有追求答案要这么全面也可以。。。。。。。。
特此分享，顺便听听NN意见
另，NN们，做逻辑需要把所有选项都看了再选吗？

NicoleYu

首先，我不是NN。。。
其次，我觉得把所有选项全部读完是最起码的

如果就这道题而言，其他几个选项没有说全，那么在取非的时候不能使原文结论一定不成立，那么就不是原文推论的假设

而对于更多的其他类型题目，比如support,weaken,evaluation等，选项间可能是存在力度的强弱的，那么不读完选项是无法知道哪个是最有力的支持或削弱的

所以，真的得读完所有选项啊。。。（怎么觉得自己很罗嗦呢，sigh）

xiaoxique89

B C 显然不对
如果车少了并且走的距离也短了的话， average 是不变的；
如果车多了并且走的距离变长了的话，average 也是不变的。

只有e是正确的。

windows10

逻辑只有一个正确答案，这和SC不同，SC是选最合适的答案。只有E是正确的。理解问题：Which of the following is an assumption on which the highway commissioner's claim depends?