返回列表 发帖

[求助]GWD-12-8 答案到底是哪个?

请问GWD-12-8(VERBAL)部分的第二篇阅读的第一个问题,我觉得答案应该是E啊!



怎么给我的答案是A?  我觉得A虽然也能加强,但没有E好啊!



请大N 指点!
收藏 分享

Q8 to Q10:

      Acting on the recommen-

       dation of a British government

       committee investigating the

Line       high incidence in white lead

  (5)       factories of illness among

employees, most of whom

were women, the Home Sec-

retary proposed in 1895 that

Parliament enact legislation

(10)      that would prohibit women from

holding most jobs in white lead

factories.  Although the

Women’s Industrial Defence

Committee (WIDC), formed

(15)      in 1892 in response to earlier

legislative attempts to restrict

women’s labor, did not dis-

count the white lead trade’s

potential health dangers, it

(20)      opposed the proposal, view-

       ing it as yet another instance

       of limiting women’s work

opportunities.  Also opposing

the proposal was the Society

(25)      for Promoting the Employment

of Women (SPEW), which

attempted to challenge it by

investigating the causes of ill-

ness in white lead factories.

(30)      SPEW contended, and WIDC

concurred, that controllable

conditions in such factories

       were responsible for the devel-

opment of lead poisoning.

(35)     SPEW provided convincing

evidence that lead poisoning

could be avoided if workers

were careful and clean and

      if already extant workplace

(40)     safety regulations were

stringently enforced.  How-

ever, the Women’s Trade

Union League (WTUL), which

had ceased in the late 1880’s

(45)      to oppose restrictions on

women’s labor, supported the

eventually enacted proposal,

in part because safety regu-

lations were generally not

(50)      being enforced in white lead

factories, where there were no

unions (and little prospect of

any) to pressure employers to

comply with safety regulations.


Q8:

Which of the following, if true, would most clearly support the contention attributed to SPEW in lines 30-34 (“SPEW contended … lead poisoning”) ?

         

    Those white lead factories that most strongly enforced regulations concerning worker safety and hygiene had the lowest incidences of lead poisoning among employees. The incidence of lead poisoning was much higher among women who worked in white lead factories than among women who worked in other types of factories. There were many household sources of lead that could have contributed to the incidence of lead poisoning among women who also worked outside the home in the late nineteenth century. White lead factories were more stringent than were certain other types of factories in their enforcement of workplace safety regulations.
  • Even brief exposure to the conditions typically found in white lead factories could cause lead poisoning among factory workers.

Answer:




我把原文和题目列出来了,请大家看看!

我开始选的是A,但等我看完了E后,我觉得E更好。

可是大家好象都是选的A。E怎么错了?


请大牛支招!

TOP

30-34行是说that controllable conditions in such factories were responsible for the development of lead poisoning. 意思是说工厂的条件应该对铅中毒负责。所以A正确。那些条件好卫生好的工厂里铅中毒少,正好验证了30-34行的说法。而E选项不能验证这个说法。其支持的力度远远不如A选项强烈。

TOP

E, Even brief exposure to the conditions typically found in white lead factories could cause lead poisoning among factory workers.


E中说lead对workers有毒,那就说明male和female一样会中毒,并不能说明只对female毒性大。

TOP

我选A,因为看要支持的原话,发现,原话说的是: ....can be avoided...所以,最直接的support就是要说明防护措施可以避免中毒.所以A.
E的重点在于说明防护很重要,中毒很容易.

TOP

我还是不太明白, 题目说in lines 30-34 (“SPEW contended … lead poisoning”),这里还没有提到5楼说的可以避免啊,  所以对E选项的错误我还不是很清楚啊, 谁能再给点拨点拨啊?

TOP

是不是阅读理解里面的逻辑题目, 要根据上下文来解答的?

因为这个题目就是根据30-34的下一句话来解答的

也就是说答案支持的是35句

对不对啊? 大家能不能帮忙看一看啊?

TOP

E, Even brief exposure to the conditions typically found in white lead factories could cause lead po ...
seuhongkai 发表于 2010-12-28 06:51



    但这是作为一个男人的观点阿,那些女权主义者什么时候把男人当人看过呢?

TOP

呵呵,
"但这是作为一个男人的观点阿,那些女权主义者什么时候把男人当人看过呢?"

这句话说得好心酸的样子啊

TOP

返回列表

站长推荐 关闭


美国top10 MBA VIP申请服务

自2003年开始提供 MBA 申请服务以来,保持着90% 以上的成功率,其中Top10 MBA服务成功率更是高达95%


查看