一道JJ题的讨论:

raonx

一道JJ题的讨论:

结婚的年轻人比不结婚的年轻人活的长，并不因为是结婚导致长寿，是由于结婚的人有更少的不良嗜好，例如抽烟，酗酒。support
选的，同样有不良嗜好，结了婚的人更容易戒除。
My answer is different from old JJ. My answer: Single people who have health lifestyles can live as long as married people who also have health lifestyles. (Open to discussion.)

————————————————————————
两个答案我觉得都有一定的道理啊。大家觉得呢？

我个人认为: 同样有不良嗜好，结了婚的人更容易戒除 说明结婚是长寿的原因.因而WEAKEN 了结论并不因为是结婚导致长寿. 所以问SUPPORT 应为:Single people who have health lifestyles can live as long as married people who also have health lifestyles.

请高人指点谢了!

tongxun

你不觉得相反吗？若结婚与不结婚同样使人长寿，结婚还有什么作用？（从提来说啊，哈哈）

raonx

是相反啊!那就没有对的了?

tongxun

题目不是问：例如抽烟，酗酒。support 吗？若结婚与不结婚一样，那不就削弱了吗！对吗？

raonx

谢谢 ! tongxun

tongxun

我们欢迎你！

blueocean

I am reading the old post.  

I kind of agree of the answer should be:
Single people who have health lifestyles can live as long as married people who also have health lifestyles.

Because if the single people who have health lifestyle can't live as long as married people, it means there must be some other reason (other than health lifestyle ) cause their life span difference.

On the other hand, the answer" married people" can quit bad health habit easily "just explained why they have healthier habit, not to support the conclusion.