大牛们帮我看看这道逻辑题吧~~不胜感激~

f2050711489

A brand of cough syrup comes with a measuring cup attached so that customers can measure the proper dosage. A consultant has pointed out that this cup is unnecessary, since most customers have measuring cups at home. Since the cups increase the cost of packaging the cough syrup and reduce the total number of units that can be shipped in a standard package, the consultant advises that the company can increase its net revenue on this product (total revenue minus total costs) by selling the cough syrup without the measuring cups.

A. Studies have shown that customers who use cough syrup without a measuring cup frequently take either too little or too much of the medicine, rendering the dosage either ineffective or, in cases of overdose, dangerous.

B. The company has included a measuring cup with each bottle of cough syrup for the last 18 years.
答案是A，我觉得是B啊，因为题目中已经说过most customers have measuring cups at home，所以为什么还要考虑without a measuring cup呢？

aeolusero二

Most = 51 to 100 of 100.  if 49% customers are going to be put in danger, the proposal would lead to huge losses to the company due to the future lawsuits filed againt the company . . . let alone the loss of human lives.

joliegu

B) is just repeating the premise offered in the passage with a number in years.

mba2013

楼主好，我说说我的思路吧~
这道题应该是加强题吧~
我觉得这应该是原因——结果~
原因：customer觉得没有也行&这个cup没什么用~
结果：customer可以自己测量&公司可以卖没有cup的以增加收入~

那么好了，这是加强题~加强，意味着：文中的理由（原因）特别对~换言之就是：加强原因~
看A，前半句很明显，“either too little or too much ”意味着：customer自己测量也行，也挺准的~
        后半句则为了说明，原因这么做，没什么负的影响。

对于B,我第一眼看到就觉得这个不对，理由很简单，和原因没什么关系。我觉得做题时千万不要自己“多想”。你看哈，b说这公司用cup这么年了。显然和“measure准不准，cup有没有”没什么关系，所以b自然是错的~

f2050711489

谢谢你啊~才发现我就是多想了~我本来是觉得已经用了这么多年，很多老客户就已经有了这个cup。。。我多想的还不只一点点啊羞愧。。。