OG13 CR19 大牛求教！

JessicaHuo

A major network news organization experienced a drop in viewership in the week following the airing of a controversial report on the economy. The network also received a very large number of complaints regarding the report. The network, however, maintains that negative reactions to the report had nothing to do with its loss of viewers
　　Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the network’s position?
　　(A) The other major network news organizations reported similar reductions in viewership during the same week.
　　(B) The viewers who registered complaints with the network were regular viewers of the news organization’s programs.
　　(C) Major network news organizations publicly attribute drop in viewership to their own reports only when they receive complaints about those reports.
(D) This was not the first time that this network news organization has aired a controversial report on the economy that has inspired viewers to complain to the network.
(E) Most network news viewers rely on network news broadcasts as their primary source of information regarding the economy.
the answer is A .
为什么其他organization 发生的事情能说明自己家发生的事情？不是说不能这样类比的么？什么时候同类型的事情能类比 什么时候不能呢？

chaomat1988

答案是比较出来滴，其他的都不如A靠谱。
A暗示有另外一个因素对所有Major network news organizations 施加了影响。
个人意见

stevenckguo

结论是负面评论与收视下降无关

如何增强?

a:所有有限网都在同一时间播同一套烂节目(所以如果是负面评论大家都有负面评论)

lz想选哪个?

JessicaHuo

我已开始选了C 我A一看到就排除了 我以为其他事件是不能说明这件事件的

zxc1118zxc

我觉得这个题只要读懂了就完全没有疑问
最后一句的意思是 负面的反应和观众的流失没有关系
A选项中表达的意思是：其他公司也一样 所以没关系

Ferris1992

我的问题和lz一样，一看见other就觉得无关排除了

zxc1118zxc

cause and effect reasoning
a选项说其他没播烂节目的新闻机构也收视率下降，有果无因，所以收视率下降和烂节目无关，所以支持了network’s position

henguc

OG上说C Since the network did in fact receive complaints about the report, this statement is irrelevant.
可是原文里明明就有啊。。The network also received a very large number of complaints regarding the report.
我觉得C选项是weaken啊。。。有木有牛牛能解释一下C选项啊

ozymen

我觉得C选项说：只有当这些网络组织者接到关于报告的抱怨时，他们才会把收视率降低归因于这个报告。而题目最后一句结论说：收视率降低与报告无关。。。所以C选项自然不是加强了结论