返回列表 发帖

请教一道旧prep的题

Herbicides allow cereal crops to be grown very efficiently, with virtually no competition from weeds.In Britain, partridge populations have been steadily decreasing since herbicide use became widespread.Some environmentalists claim that these birds, which live in and around cereal crop fields, are being poisoned by the herbicides.However, tests show no more than trace quantities of herbicides in partridges on herbicide-treated land.Therefore, something other than herbicide use must be responsible for the population decrease.



Which of the following, if true about Britain, most seriously weakens the argument?




(A) The elimination of certain weeds from cereal crop fields has reduced the population of the small insects that live on those weeds and that form a major part of partridge chicks' diet.




(B) Since partridges are valued as game birds, records of their population are more carefully kept than those for many other birds.




(C) Some of the weeds that are eliminated from cereal crop fields by herbicides are much smaller than the crop plants themselves and would have no negative effect on crop yield if they were allowed to grow.




(D) Birds other than partridges that live in or around cereal crop fields have also been suffering population declines.




(E) The toxins contained in herbicides typically used on cereal crops can be readily identified in the tissues of animals that have ingested them.





这道题我在网上找不到解释,看来大家对这题都很明白,但是想了很久还是不明白。我是选D的。
我的疑问在于:这道题 要削弱的是Therefore, something other than herbicide use must be responsible for the population decrease这个结论,如果是的话选A那不是就是说的确有其它原因说明题目中要说的问题吗?要削弱结论就是要加强Some environmentalists 的claim不是吗?
想来想去还是不明白,脑子转不过来,麻烦各位CDER了
收藏 分享

D应该是无关?

A是指别的原因导致了PARTRIDGE 数量减少,而且这个原因并不是因为别的herbicide,所以是答案?

菜鸟一只,我的回答不作为答案

TOP

今天早上再重新看了这一道题,我做题的时候看来是没有看到第一句话。我想这题的解题思路应该是这样的:因为Herbicides allow cereal crops to be grown very efficiently, with virtually no competition from weeds.所以Herbicides把虫都KILL了,而PARTRIDGE这只鸟要吃虫,但是因为虫都被KILL了,所以就造成的PARTRIDGE这种鸟的数量减少。这样来削弱ARGUMENT。对吗?

TOP

对。A。

TOP

这是找隐含原因的。就是说不是C,而是A导致B,然而却是C导致A的。

TOP

返回列表

站长推荐 关闭


美国top10 MBA VIP申请服务

自2003年开始提供 MBA 申请服务以来,保持着90% 以上的成功率,其中Top10 MBA服务成功率更是高达95%


查看