返回列表 发帖

请教OG10-125

Unlike the wholesale price of raw wool, the wholesale price of raw cotton has fallen considerably in the last year. Thus, although the retail price of cotton clothing at retail clothing stores has not yet fallen, it will inevitably fall.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument above?

(A)The cost of processing raw cotton for cloth has increased during the last year.

(E)The cost of harvesting raw cotton for cloth has increased during the last year.

答案是A

E为什么不对呢?

这两个有什么区别?

谢谢:)

收藏 分享

Notice that there are a couple of different prices.

The conclusion of the argument is that retail price of cotton clothing will fall. To support the conclusion, the arguer uses an analogy between wholesale price of raw cotton and wholesale price of raw wool, to predict that former will fall.

(A) best weakens the argument by pointing out that even if such analogy is appropriate, the cost of processing raw cotton for cloth has increased, contributing to higher total cost for retail price of cotton clothing.

As OG points out, even if cost of harvesting raw cotton has increased (note: E does not say "for cloth" -- please check the OG), the most we can conclude is that wholesale price of cotton will increase. This contradicts a more fundamental assumption of the whole argument (the analogy), so is not the correct answer.

In my opinion, if A were not a choice, E could also serve as an answer, but A is closer to the argument than E is.

TOP

不太同意楼上的大大, harvesting 是在wholesale之前的, 所以cost of harvesting是不是比以前高了或者是低了,并不影响结论的,因为题目中已经给出wholesale price降低了。

TOP

同意3楼大人的观点,raw cotton的价格应该已经包括了harvesting在内了 

而processing是发生在把raw cotton变成cotton cloth的过程中

TOP

我想问一下OG对B选项的解释是什么意思?没看懂。

B is incorrect because the argument focuses on incorrect becasuse it in effect denies that lower wholesale prices for cotton have been offset by rising operating costs.

谢谢啦~~~ 

TOP

555555~~~~怎么没人理呀~~~~

NN出来帮下我好吗?

不胜感激~~~

TOP

返回列表

站长推荐 关闭


美国top10 MBA VIP申请服务

自2003年开始提供 MBA 申请服务以来,保持着90% 以上的成功率,其中Top10 MBA服务成功率更是高达95%


查看