[讨论] 每日一贴 4.23

apan

issue 57
"Everywhere, it seems, there are clear and positive signs that people are becoming more respectful of one another's differences."

argument 43
The following appeared in an article in the health section of a newspaper.
"There is a common misconception that university hospitals are better than community or private hospitals. This notion is unfounded, however: the university hospitals in our region employ 15 percent fewer doctors, have a 20 percent lower success rate in treating patients, make far less overall profit, and pay their medical staff considerably less than do private hospitals. Furthermore, many doctors at university hospitals typically divide their time among teaching, conducting research, and treating patients. From this it seems clear that the quality of care at university hospitals is lower than that at other kinds of hospitals."

apan

issue 57.       
“看来有明显和确实的迹象说明所有地方的人们都变得对彼此的不同越来越尊重。”

argument 43.       
报纸的健康板块上的文章：
"有一种普遍的错误观念认为大学医院比社区或私人医院更好。这个想法是无根据的，我们地区的大学医院较之私人医院，少雇15%的医生，对患者的治愈率要低20%，总体利润要小得多，给一户员工的待遇比私人医院低很多。而且，很多大学医院的医生将他们的时间分为教学，直到研究和看病几部分。从此可明显看出大学医院的服务质量比其他医院低。"

gladys

Issue 57

Stance:

I agree with the view to the extent that it is a trend nowadays that people are becoming
more respectful and tolerant of one another's difference. But this trend does not mean this
promising phenomenon is existing in everywhere of our world.

1.Internationally, diplomatic dialogue has been advocated by many governments to solve problems.

2.In China, the democracy bred in our society is encouraging people to have their own
characters and personalities, a huge contrast with the situate two decades ago.

3. However, the hate crimes, violence and terrorism indicate that we still have a long
way toward respectful and tolerant societies.

gladys

Argument 43

1.The first problem with this arguement is thatit assumes the university hospital is
representative of the university hospitals as a whole.

2. The second problems is that it cites the number of doctors employed,
overall profit and salaries of medical staffs as reliable indicators of quality of
medical care.

3.The third problem is that the comparison of success rates between the university hosptial
and other hospitals is a vague and unfair one.

4.We can not safely conclusion that the university hospitals are offering poorer quality of care than other hospitals from the fact that the doctors in university hospitals dividing their time among teaching, researching and treating patients.

[此贴子已经被作者于2003-4-23 12:08:03编辑过]