Prep 159题请教

vincentwh

一道Prep 的题目请教

159. As the former chair of the planning board for 18 consecutive years and a board member for 28 years, Joan Philkill attended more than 400 meetings and reviewed more than 700 rezoning application.

(A) As the former

(B) The former

(C) Former

(D) She was

(E) As the

答案：E

为什么说 As the former chair of … for 18 consecutive years不符合逻辑？谓语attended如果用former chair也不合逻辑？谢谢！！！

Chowmeiner

首先看主要子句是attended，代表描述过去事实，所以他那时未卸任。不能用former，句意变成「以前董事的身份，连续叁加... 年」。

当然你可能会想为何不是以「前..的身份」连续叁加，不过句子用连续...，总计...这种总结的语气，是要强调描述他人在位的事迹。

vincentwh

非常感谢！！

ShawnHuHu

我觉得应该不对，因为我认为As是在这引导一个状语，表达Joan这个人的状态。

同位语是为了表达前面一系列动作对后面的影响，而且印象里都是在后面，如果The

chair of the planning board for 18 consecutive years and a board member

for 28 years 把它当成同位语，就不能表现出那种状态。

请指教！

carollai

我觉得同位语不一定就放在后面,作为主语的同位语,一般是放在前面的....我也

不明白如果作为同位语可不可以...

judy_zhaoli

我觉得从语法上来说应该是没有错的吧 但是在这种语境中曲解了文章的意思~~只是

个人观点