Board logo

标题: l9 [打印本页]

作者: steven.wei    时间: 2003-1-17 22:41     标题: l9

102. Years after writing the comic opera    The Bartered Bride , the Czech
composer Bedrich Smetana  claimed that he wrote that work in reaction
to contentions that he was too much like the German composer Richard
Wagner and could not write anything lighthearted. But Smetana must have
either misremembered or misrepresented the facts, since music critics
did not begin to publish commentary comparing Smetana to Wagner until
some time after  The Bartered Bride  was first performed.

Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

      A Smetana never intentionally imitated the style of Wagner's operas.  
      B Smetana did not write The Bartered Bride  simply in response to
       unpublished opinions of his friends.  
      C Music critics did not begin to pay attention to Smetana's work until
       after he wrote  The Bartered B ride .  
      D Most music critics of Smetana's time favored lighthearted operas
       over more serious operas.  
      E Some music critics considered  The Bartered Bride to be too much
like Wagner's operas to succeed as a comedy.
作者: Louisa_xy    时间: 2003-1-20 14:04

C
作者: steven.wei    时间: 2003-1-20 18:35

l8
这道题对The argument above proceeds by有点蒙,从根本上就理解错了。
作者: Louisa_xy    时间: 2003-1-20 18:37

这个argument是如何论证的
作者: steven.wei    时间: 2003-1-20 22:18

对不起,这题答案应该是B
作者: 1stzhang    时间: 2003-1-21 23:28

我觉得这个问题应该用相关法做.
A是无关的.B有关且求同.C有关也求同.D是无关答案.E主观描述,更是无关答案.关键是看B和C中间哪个是支持,哪个是假设.
当然,判断的方法有很多种,可以把B取非,就是S没有写东西;C取非,就是批评家没有注意S的作品.明显B的范围大于C.所以B是假设,C是支持.




欢迎光临 国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA (http://forum.topway.org/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2