Board logo

标题: 请教一道逻辑题 [打印本页]

作者: rhou88    时间: 2003-1-4 09:41     标题: 请教一道逻辑题

Some United States psychologists have concluded that one specific set of parental behaviors toward children always signifies acceptance and a second set always signifies rejection, for there is remarkable agreement among investigators about the maternal bahviors designated as indicative of these parental attitudes.

The conclusion of the psychologists mentioned above logically depends on the assumption that
A) most maternal bahviors have been interpreted as conveying either acceptance or rejection.
B) the maternal behaviors indicating acceptance or rejection are exhibited by father as well.
C).....
D).....
E).....

答案是B. 但是我认为题目中的原因(最后一句话for there is.....)不是已经表明了B的意思吗?为什么B是假设呢?答案A不是挺好吗? 刚好把结论(第一句话)和原因联系起来。

请各位大侠指教。rhou88@yahoo.com
[em27]
作者: 回家过年    时间: 2003-1-4 11:59

这题说实话我没看太懂!不过做为假设题选项,有MOST感觉不舒服.根据你的解释,这个答案B好像是"A可行或A有意义"(陈向东逻辑)虽然像是重复提干,但是作为答案也没什么不好吧.
偶的阅读能力还是急待提高,
作者: justag    时间: 2003-1-4 13:15

if you can tell the difference between maternal(in the last sentence) and parental(in the first sentence), this problem is not difficult at all.

BTW: I can't quite understand the rules of Chen and it seems I need to train myself more




欢迎光临 国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA (http://forum.topway.org/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2