Board logo

标题: [求助]CR大全-20-4 [打印本页]

作者: zhangpeiyu01    时间: 2006-9-22 06:39     标题: [求助]CR大全-20-4

懇請NN 們幫個忙~

Q4.

Samples from a ceramic vase found at a tomb in Sicily prove that the vase was manufactured in Greece. Since the occupant of the tomb died during the reign of a Sicilian ruler who lived 2,700 years ago, the location of the vase indicates that there was trade between Sicily and Greece 2,700 years ago.

Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?

(A) Sicilian potters who lived during the reign of the ruler did not produce work of the same level of quality as did Greek potters. ( irrelevant )

(B) Sicilian clay that was used in the manufacture of pottery during the ruler’s reign bore little resemblance to Greek clay used to manufacture pottery at that time. ( irrelevant )

(C) At the time that the occupant of the tomb was alive, there were ships capable of transporting large quantities of manufactured goods between Sicily and Greece.

(D) The vase that was found at the Sicilian tomb was not placed there many generations later by descendants of the occupant of the tomb.D

(E) The occupant of the tom was not a member of the royal family to which the Sicilian ruler belonged. ( irrelevant )

ANS: D

1) 請教為何 choice D is correct ?

    2) 首先我排除ABE, 因為是無關選項

 我的思路如下:

è Samples from a ceramic vase found at a tomb in Sicily prove that the vase was manufactured in Greece. ( Fact )

Since the occupant of the tomb died during the reign of a Sicilian ruler who lived 2,700 years ago, the location of the vase indicates that there was trade between Sicily and Greece 2,700 years ago. ( conclusion )

之間求 assumption, 請問 choice C 為何非正確選項?  

( CR 現在程度有待急救, 請各位NN 大力相助 ~ 感激不盡)


作者: casualwalk    时间: 2006-9-22 13:17

Fact 1: Samples from a ceramic vase found at a tomb in Sicily prove that the vase was manufactured in Greece.
Fact 2: the occupant of the tomb died during the reign of a Sicilian ruler who lived 2,700 years ago.

Conclusion: there was trade between Sicily and Greece 2,700 years ago.


Assumption题,用"取反"。

D取反:  "花瓶是在墓主死后很久才被放进去的"。 直接推翻原来的推理和结论, 所以D是必要条件(assumption).

C取反: "在墓主生前,并没有"ships capable of transporting LARGE QUANTITIES of manufactured goods"在两地之间运输"。 并不影响原文的逻辑,因为如果有小容量的货船,原文同样成立。所以C不是必要条件。

作者: zhangpeiyu01    时间: 2006-9-23 20:08

謝謝解答!~

剛我又重新翻了一下OG所有關於assumption的題型~

稍稍有所領悟了~






欢迎光临 国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA (http://forum.topway.org/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2