I am a Canadian applicant and looked into these two programs in depth. I have worked in a telecom company based in Vancouver that employs students from both schools.
Here are my 2 cents from a Canadian point of view:
1. Reputation wise, I think York is better perceived by employers. It is generally more reputable in the international scene (because of it's iMBA program), and especially in Toronto. UBC Sauder is VERY regional. I mean graduates RARELY go outside of BC/Vancouver.
2. Quality wise, I think the 2 schools are comparable. Both use a mix of lecture/case methods. Ivey is the only one in Canada that uses exclusively case based method. Queens are Toronto are more quantitative.
What's your target industry? Because the two schools are both relatively speaking regional schools ( where the alums are based, York - TO, UBC - Vancouver), so I would recommend look into your target industry in both provinces (BC/ON). If your target industry has better representation in TO, then go there.
If I were you, I'd go to York. Toronto simply has more companies/corporate presence than BC. In BC it's mostly mining, forestry, real estate, and tourism. However, if you want to work in one of those industries, may be UBC is more suitable for you.作者: thinkingape 时间: 2011-4-20 06:44
York has a joint EMBA program with Kellogg, so you might meet some of the students from Northwestern and develop valuable contacts.作者: sagamba 时间: 2011-4-21 06:50
I appreciate your response to my question and your advice. Your analysis of strengths of Schulich and Sauder is very helpful for me to understand both schools. Did you apply to Schulich as well? Which BS are you going to?作者: thinkingape 时间: 2011-4-22 22:13
I am glad that you have found my notes helpful! I applied to Ivey in Canada, because I liked the case based method. I also got into a US school, and plans to go there because I already have worked in Canada.
Also, are you aiming for immigration? If you are coming over from China directly, and plans to start a career in Canada, then I'd choose York. TO has a lot more opportunities than Vancouver, especially in Finance/Consulting/Marketing. And there are TONS of York alums in TO (both undergrad and MBA).
Please feel free for to reach out if you have other questions.
Best,作者: sagamba 时间: 2011-4-23 07:24
Your posts come so fast. Huh..
Ivey is very strong both in real strengths and reputation. But I did not applied to it because I prefer a two-year MBA program. Rotman is the ideal one. However, my GMAT and GPA are not that high to satisfy its adcom. I heard it is very strict with academic background, from which many Chinese applicants had suffered.
I am a PR actually and live in Vancouver(I sent you PM. Check it ). My professional experience had mainly focused on Internaional Business and Marketing. Based on your comments, I guess Schulich must be more attractive. By the way, I also want to experience a different life from that in Vancouver.
Check my PM.
Cheers,
欢迎光临 国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA (http://forum.topway.org/)
