Board logo

标题: 求助,为什么OG10-CR-114的C选项不可以做答案 [打印本页]

作者: powergreatwall    时间: 2007-6-13 01:33     标题: 求助,为什么OG10-CR-114的C选项不可以做答案

请问OG10-CR-114C选项有什么错呢?

题目是这样的

The more frequently employees take time to exercise during working hours each week, the fewer sick days they take. Even employees who exercise only once a week during working hours take less sick time than those who do not exercise. Therefore, if companies started fitness programs, the absentee rate in those companies would decrease significantly.

Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument above?

A)    Employees who exercise during working hours occasionally fall asleep for short periods of time after they exercise.

B)     Employees who are frequently absent are the least likely to cooperate with or to join a corporate fitness program.

C)    Employees who exercise only once a week in their company’s fitness program usually also exercise after work.

D)    Employees who exercise in their company’s fitness program use their working time no more productively than those who do not exercise.

E)     Employees who exercise during working hours take slightly longer lunch breaks than employees who do not exercise.

OG答案是B。偶对B答案没有问题,但认为C也可以做答案。

我对C的推理是:原文说:那些每周在办公时间锻炼一次的员工请病假缺席的可能性低。选项C说:那些每周在办公时间锻炼一次的员工,也通常在下班后锻炼身体,这里就给说了一个他因,就是“下班后锻炼对降低缺席率的作用很大”。所以,如果公司的结论是,推出办公时间的健身计划,员工的请假缺席率会降低。这个计划可能失败,因为它忽略了选项C提出的他因“下班后锻炼很重要”,所以选项C起到了对结论的weaken作用。

不知道偶的推理错在哪里,请大家帮忙看看,想了好久了还是想不通,谢谢


作者: paopaodong    时间: 2007-6-20 08:53

C选项按楼主的推理 确实有可能

但是也只是有可能 而且楼主的推理有点过了 不够直接

美国人的思维不像中国人那样复杂的 


作者: flamedream    时间: 2007-6-20 16:17

be careful with the word "even one exercise"

it doesn't mean that all the employees do exercise once a week

therefore, even if C is right, it will not undermine the conclusion

Miles






欢迎光临 国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA (http://forum.topway.org/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2