返回列表 发帖

GWD-23-25(GWD-32-14) 实在想不明白啊

Manufacturing site location is an important consideration in determining the optimal deployment of a firm’s production resources, but one that is usually given only limited attention. Decisions about location are often based purely on quantitative analyses that trade off transportation costs, economies of scale, and other cost-based variables. This practice, however, can lead to suboptimal results, as decision-makers tend to focus only on easily quantifiable factors. A further disadvantage of strictly cost-based methods is that they tend to focus on cost advantage factors, which are often transitory
        
Government regulations, tax systems, and exchange rates can quickly change. Strategies based on such parameters may eventually be rendered obsolete by the very factors that first created an advantage.


In contrast, qualitative issues, which are frequently neglected in choosing manufacturing site locations, are often central to creating and supporting a competitive advantage. For example, the level of skill possessed by the local workforce varies with location; consequently, location can affect the ability of firms to implement skill-based process technologies. When formulating a site location strategy, companies should therefore emphasize qualitative factors to ensure that the chosen strategy supports the company’s overall business strategy. Only after establishing a set of desirable location options should companies refine choices using cost-based factors.

Q14.
            
According to the passage,
            
analysis of quantitative factors is best used for which of the following?

A.
Determining strategies for offsetting qualitative disadvantages in manufacturing site locations

B.
Evaluating manufacturing site-location parameters affecting long-term competitive advantage

C.
Choosing manufacturing site locations that have access to optimal workforce populations

D.
Narrowing manufacturing site-location options arrived it through qualitative analysis

E.
Making decisions about business considerations other than location of manufacturing sites

答案给的是C,我觉得好奇怪。首先这个analysis of quantitative factors在文中第一段作者是持否定态度的,问题中竟然问"best used for which of the following",于是我就到第二段去找,发现作者赞同的方法是现用qualitative 方法找出 a set of desirable location option,然后再refine choice using cost-based factors. 而cost based facotors根据第一段的描述,其实就是quantative 的方法。所以我觉得应该是D 啊

这个C文章中哪里提到啊?

想不明白,这套题目的阅读做的想撞墙了

谢谢



收藏 分享

对,我也认为是D

原文中最后一句话 "Only after establishing a set of desirable location options should companies refine choices using cost-based factors."特别是那个REFINE和D是契合的.

TOP

严重同意楼上!可是答案错了吗?看了这么久GWD,答案如果有争议都会有很多的帖子哎,可是为什么没有呢?

TOP

正好也在纳闷这道题,我本来也选D,现在看懂了,应该选C

文章最后一句:Only after establishing a set of desirable location options should companies refine choices using cost-based factors.说明先用qualitative的方法筛选出几个候选的,再用quantitative的方法精选

C.      Choosing manufacturing site locations that have access to optimal workforce populations 是指location已经经过qualitative筛选过了,最后几个剩下的再用quantitative





D.      Narrowing manufacturing site-location options arrived it through qualitative analysis 是指用quantitative的方法先来缩小筛选范围,与原文意思相反,注意本选项中的narrowing是指用quantitative来缩小,而非是已经缩小过的选择

TOP

正好也在纳闷这道题,我本来也选D,现在看懂了,应该选C

文章最后一句:Only after establishing a set  ...
chamcham 发表于 2011-8-13 09:09



还是应该选D.

因为文中说qualitative issues, which are frequently neglected in choosing manufacturing site locations, are often central to creating and supporting a competitive advantage. For example, the level of skill possessed by the local workforce varies with location ...

注意for example,作者只是举了使用qualitative analysis的一个例子而已,也就是说qualitative analysis还有其他一些crucial的考量点,所以choosing manufacturing site-location options时,即使那些options是在考虑过optimal workforce populations的基础上选出的,但仍然可能还需要再考虑其他一些qualitative的因素,然后再用quantitative analysis. 所以C is vague.

TOP

同意选C,解释得很好

TOP

1,D选项分析:Narrowing manufacturing site-location options arrived 【it】 through qualitative analysis
如果去掉it。 arrived则作为过去分词修饰site-location options。D则确定无疑是正确答案。
但有了it,arrived则是动词,宾语是it,语法上也有问题。
2,C选项分析:Choosing manufacturing site locations that have access to optimal workforce populations
Workforce只是举例说明qualitative analysis的一个因素。仅根据这一个因素选择后就用quantitative factors挑选,也不严格。
3,综合,D选项中的it是误写的。因为几个选项都是现在分词从句。即使arrive做动词用,也没有必要用过去式,或者原型或者现在分词,前面也应当加个逗号区分。

TOP

返回列表

站长推荐 关闭


美国top10 MBA VIP申请服务

自2003年开始提供 MBA 申请服务以来,保持着90% 以上的成功率,其中Top10 MBA服务成功率更是高达95%


查看