问一道CR 题目

taohuaxianzi

8.CR
這是我遇到比較不同以往的題型:
(轉自CD)Anyone who pays tax will not be punished, since John is not punished, he must pay tax.
Which parallel the above statement with the similar flaw?
我選People along with dog is not lonely. Amy must have a dog, because she is lonely.

if amy has a dog, then according to condition, she must not be lonely.
is this really the problem in the test?
think should be :
People along with dog is not lonely. Amy must have a dog, because she is NOTlonely.

renprince

我選People along with dog is not lonely. Amy must have a dog, because she is lonely.

不对吧?正好相反吧?

if Amy have a dog, she won't be longly.

Comparing with the parent sentense:

since John is not punished, he must pay tax.

if John pays tax, he won't be punished.

是不是这么分析 啊?你把原文一起打出来,大家才能一起做分析.