GWD 3-39 求正确答案

lilydenris

Minivanscarry as many as seven passengers and, compared with most sport utilityvehicles, cost less, get better gas mileage, allow passengers to get in and out more easily,and have a smoother ride.
A.    Minivans carry as many as seven passengers and, compared with most sportutility vehicles, cost less,
B.     Minivans, which carry as many as seven passengers, compared with mostsport utility vehicles, they cost less,
C.     Minivans carry as many as seven passengers, in comparison with most sportutility vehicles, and have a lower cost, they
D.     Minivans, carrying as many as sevenpassengers, compared with most sport utility vehicles, cost less,
E.     Minivans, which carry as many as seven passengers, compared with mostsport utility vehicles the cost is lower, and they
Prep 2008 说答案是A 我选D，GWD里的答案是D 求正确答案
怎么都看A不顺眼，如果没有那个and我倒要犹豫一下
Minivans carry as many as seven passengers, compared with most sport utility vehicles, cost less...这个结构是对的么？求解释
尼玛临近考试每错一道都心烦意乱。。跑到GWD那看解释居然发现正确答案是D orz

liulu007

哈哈，楼主~~~握个手~~~我也快考试了~~~我今天也刚纠结完这个题，一个星期前做的时候对的，今天做错了，因为脑子里老想着后面好像还有一道差不多的题哈哈！言归正传

我还是觉得A比较好，其实A是两个句子并列，【M carry as many as seven passengers】and 【M】，（compared with most sport utility vehicles, ）cost less, get...allow...and have...
题目太坏了，主语省了中间还加个修饰语
D 我是觉得 compared with会修饰歧义，向前向后都行，这种分词前后逗号的，还真心要小心

lilydenris

我觉得M carry,cost, get better, allow, have 是平行的 所以应该是have前

有and，carry后有AND还省略主语就很奇怪

compared with我觉得只能修饰前面的M啊 后面没东西可以给她修饰呀我觉得

liulu007

我是那么觉得的，平时我们说ed/ing在句首，修饰s，其实是修饰的v，逻辑上与S一致，现在 M, carrying...,  compared...., cost less... compared修饰哪个V？虽然逻辑上感觉修饰哪个逻辑主语都一样是M，但是，compared实际是状语，D中，可以理解修饰主句谓语，也可以理解修饰前面的修饰语carrying

lilydenris

修饰来修饰去真的太尼玛麻烦了
看很多解释都会提到说因为哪个修饰错了所以不对之类 就觉得我做题的时间根本

不会想到那么多Orz

liulu007

LZ，和你同感啊~~~
有时候做做题就晕了！！！哎~~~特别一掐时间，有时候直接晕菜~~~哈哈~~~没事，加油哦~~~