OG12 Q100 指代问题 呼唤NN~~

taotao35

100. The stars, some of them at tremendous speeds, are
motion just as the planets are, yet being so far away
from Earth that their apparent positions in the sky do
not change enough for their movement to be observe
during a single human lifetime.
(A) The stars, some of them at tremendous speeds
are in motion just as the planets are, yet being
(B) Like the planets, the stars are in motion, some
of them at tremendous speeds, but they are
(C) Although like the planets the stars are in motion
some of them at tremendous speeds, yet
(D) As the planets, the stars are in motion, some of
them at tremendous speeds, but they are
(E) The stars are in motion like the planets, some o
which at tremendous speeds are in motion but

  这题选B，用排除法很好做出来~但我想问的是B选项中some of them 指代不会有歧义么？可以指代planets也可以指代stars?  个人觉得应该改成some of which~~请教NN~~

zhengqingku

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in motion, some of which are at tremendous speeds.
The stars are in motion, some are at tremendous speeds.  ==> 应该是some at tremendous speeds
The stars are in motion, some of them at tremendous speeds.

也就是说如果你要变成which的话，后面跟着的应该是完整的从句，而非只是一个【介宾名词】

taotao35

some of them是独立主格的用法啊，我记得Manhattan里有写的。
正确的形式有以下几种：
The stars are in  ...
zhengqingku 发表于 2011-12-25 20:37

原来some of them 是独立主格结构，之前我还真不知道。Manhattan就看过一个精简版的而且只看了一遍，果断力度不够啊~~~最后二十几天再恶补下语法，希望不要二战了~~谢谢bat~

eefafa1

那些时光，再也回不去了。 原来，不知不觉中，我们已经错过了，都成了所谓的曾经。
结婚前夕，我妈对我说：励志名言可不是你嫁给他就这么简单的一件事，还要和他的家人搞好关系。他家人那么多，你要是都能处得好，那才是励志电影的真本事。蜜月一结束，他去了外地工作，我们不得不两地分居。没想到，这反倒成全了我们的婚姻。因为思念，我们的励志歌曲又恢复到恋爱时那么热烈。距离能产生美，婚姻也一样。有了孩子后，农村的公婆来帮忙照顾我坐月子。结果，他们不仅带来了老公二姐的女儿，还带来了老公大哥7岁的小女儿,整天像跑火车一样不得安宁。那天，他们吵嘲着叫我上网购买个励志文章的碧玺净水器，我也只能依着他们。转眼，我们结婚十年了。我和他早已磨合成天下最平常的烟火夫妻，一起下厨做饭，视对方的父母如同自己的父母，他的哥哥嫂子们，也常来常往，亲如一家。
就如励志签名所言：其实，婚姻是两个人共同成长的过程，在这其中有欢笑也有泪水。