OG12 115 E选项解释不懂

youngerlee

Gall’s hypothesis of there being different mental functions localized in different parts of the brain is
widely accepted today.
(A) of there being different mental functions localized in different parts of the brain is widely accepted today
(B) of different mental functions that are localized in different parts of the brain is widely accepted today
(C) that different mental functions are localized in different parts of the brain is widely accepted today
(D) which is that there are different mental functions localized in different parts of the brain is widely accepted today
(E) which is widely accepted today is that there are different mental functions localized in different parts of the brain

OG 中对E项的错误归结为E Which is widely accepted today implies that Gall’s other theories are not accepted today,distorting the meaning of the sentence.  但是我怎么读都感觉不出来“implies that Gall’s other theories are not accepted today”这层意思，觉得E项的错误就是把原句的句子重心改变了，不知道NN们有什么看法？

applejsjs

我猜是因为，g的假设，哪个假设？是那个已经被大众接受了的假设。那意味着还有其他没被接受的。因为要特别强调这一点，证明这一点与众不同……仅供参考……还请指正～

Raquel

这个选项改变句意是肯定的了。

这里的根本问题在于which的前面没有“，”也就是说是限定性的定语从句，所起的修饰作用是限定先行词的范围，所以说the hypothesis which is widely accepted就是限定这个hypothesis是在Gall的那些被接受了的假设范围内。。也就可以合理推出他还有没被接受的假设。。总之就是改变了先行词被限定的范围而改变了句子的原来意思。

所以OG的解释没有问题。。只是有点跳跃。

laurawang2234

同问E的解释~

echo19872010

which跟的内容应该是去掉也对句子意思没有影响的，这里显然不行
我觉得这里明显缀余了，而且which前该有“，”才符合GMAT风格
个人意见哈

msufcufou

which不可以直接接在名词的后面，要有逗号或者是介词。
hypothesis，fact等词后常接同位语。这应该是这个题的考点。
至于E选项OG的解释的意思应该是，原先做同位语的that从句改为了表语从句。个人的意见，仅供参考

chriswendy35

B选项为什么不对， 有人给我讲下吗？