关于白勇的语法题目

jojofgasw

19. The Forbidden City in Beijing, from which the emperors ruled by heavenly mandate, was a site which a commoner or foreigner could not enter without any permission, on pain of death.

(C) which no commoner or foreigner could enter without permission

不太理解该句的结构，谁能帮分析一下？特别是随后部分on pain of death，不知道他是跟那句连着的啊？觉得这句话很突兀。谢了！还有without 后面为啥不能加any呢？fficeffice" /> [em27]

himba

on pain of death是一句俗语，意思为：违者，以死论处。fficeffice" />

至于without后面不能加any是从逻辑上表达更简洁，就想中文说的‘没有’和‘没有一些’同理都是没有，所以any就是多余。

hsWang

其实两个which从句都是插入语的角色，去掉两个从句，句子的主干就非常清晰了。


The forbudden city in beijing was a site on pain of death.


without permission 从语感上感觉要强于without any permission

hsWang

without any permission也没什么语法错误，只是比较而言，不如前者