关于whether or not用法

zhouyeying

如题：
Researchers agreed that the study of new treatments for heart attack patients was extremely important but more research was needed to determine that balloon angioplasty preceded with ultrasound was or was not any better for heart attack paients than
the balloon procedure by itself.
A. more research was needed to determine that balloon angioplasty preceded with ultrasound was or was not any better for heart attack patients than
B. more research was needed or determining whether or not balloon angioplasty preceded by ultrasound is any better for heart attack patients than is
C. that more research was neede to determine whether balloon angioplasty preceded by ultrasound is any better for heart attack patients than
D. that more research was needed to determine that balloon angioplasty preceded with ultrasound was any better for heart attack patients than
E. that more research  was needed for determining that balloon antigioplasty preceded by ultrasound is or is not any better for heart attack patients than is
我想知道为什么选B，不选C。不是说whether or not出现永远错吗？

gotomba

选B吗？？我从第一直觉认为应该有个that引导，所以我的判断是CDE来进入下一轮。

queenie924

这里我觉得考的是is的用法。没有is会有歧义的，会有误解为is结构以后的比较。whether or not 这个我我以前貌似听到过新东方有这么一说。但是在Manhattan上面54页有whether to do something or not的用法。个人认为or not是简洁原则，非correctness原则。简洁原则次于correctness原则。个人理解。等待大牛更正

gotomba

考的包括：but后面要不要that引导从句、表示目的用for doing和to do、whether（or not）、平行结构中，后面的be动词要不要省略。

总之我认为c是综合各种条件之后的最佳。

bloomers

这道题不就是选C么？我的疑问是C中的时态为什么是现在时？agreed后面的从句不应该都应该和agreed这个过去时段保持一致？还是因为这里是事实？但不是很明显啊？求大N解释！

laurawang2234

关于这道题prep2008语法有解释：
1.    agree that…but that…，宾语从句的平行that不能省，使句子更加清晰。
2.    need做实意动词的用法是：
need (sb.) to do sth；
need sth for sth；
sth needs n./doing/to be done(接名词性成分)；
3.    whether or not的使用：
在引导宾从的时候只能够用whether，而不能加or not，否则累赘；
在引导状从的时候必须加上or not，即whether or not。
4.    precede的惯用搭配是：A preceded by B（意思为B先进，然后A进）。

zhouyeying

C：如果不是be to do 改成
not until almost 1900 did scholars and critics  begin seriously to study
是否正确呢？

zhouyeying

哦 D中 强调了when   也就是说何时开始研究   原意是开始研究~
恩 这个明白了~~

suners

回复 8# zhouyeying


    你说的是哪道题？