prep-1-１４０ 用between为什么错呢？

乱草花儿

140

 

In human hearing, subtle differences in how the two ears hear a given sound help the listener determine the qualities of that sound.

 

(A) in how the two ears hear a given sound help the listener determine

 

(B) in the two ears hearing a given sound help the listener in determining

 

(C) in how a sound is heard by the two ears helps the listener determine

 

(D) between how the two ears hear a given sound helps the listener in determining

 

(E) between how a sound is heard by the two ears help the listener in determining

 

 

句子结构：…, … differences in… help the listener determine…

 

 

主语是differences，谓语是help，双宾语分别是listener和determine.

 

(D) between应该是用于表达“二者之间”的含义，用于此处不正确；helps应该是help.

 

(E) between应该是用于表达“二者之间”的含义，用于此处不正确；被动语态的表达没有必要.

 

可是这里 subtle differences in how the two ears hear a given sound

 

two ears这里不就是两个耳朵相当于两者之间所以用between才对呀?

BruceNornia

between在GMAT中一般用于 between A and B这种结构

这里使用between的确不对

因为how the two ears hear a given sound表达的是一个意思 而不是两个并列的意思

 

 

greedier

"how a sound is heard by the two ears help the listener" is one thing.

cooperqi

2个耳朵听到的是一样的，是比较听到的各种差别。。。各种SUBTLE DIFFERENCE。。。

hlyndons

我的看法：

differences between XX and XX.  between...and...是个习惯搭配，没有见过between后面不跟and，而跟一个句子的。

但是用了difference in，后面就没有这个问题了，不用再跟一个and。

所以对这里的情况，后面是一个how开头的句子，用differences in更符合英语的表达习惯。