求助 GWD3-Q18 Help Help !!!

pangpangshin

Which of following most logically completes the argument?
The last members of a now-extinct species of a European wild deer called the giant dear lived in Ireland about 16,000 years ago.Prehistoric cave paintings in France depict this animal as having a large hump on its back.Fossils of this animal, however, do not show any hump.Nevertheless, there is no reason to conclude that the cave paintings are therefore inaccurate in this regard, since ______.

A       some prehistoric cave paintings in France also depict other animals as having a hump
B       fossils of the giant deer are much more common in Ireland than in France
C       animal humps are composed of fatty tissue, which dose not fossilize
D       the cave paintings of the giant deer were painted well before 16,000 years ago
E       only one currently existing species of deer has any anatomical feature that even remotely resembles a hump



A答案错在哪里呢？？？？

pangpangshin

Get it , your answer is very accurate . Thanks a lot .

zhaoyiqing

A is irrelevant since it mentions other animals in France which are not the

subject in the stimulus.

bettyofariN

可不可以这么理解，A选项中没有体现出argument中的关于化石对画的推导，所以A选项不对。

pangpangshin

有点意思了 3Q~~~~~

pfullsomer

A显然是无关的。即使有其他动物也是有hump 的，那个画依然是不准确的，因为其他动物有bump，giant deer可能没有，马和骆驼都生活在现代，你无法说因为马是没有bump的，所以你画出来的骆驼没有bump也是准确的。无论如何它没有画出真正giant deer的长相。
现在要说明画并非不准确，你必须要解释那个化石的证据，C项说明化石没有准确地表现出giant deer的形象，所以化石无法证明壁画的画的不准确。