返回列表 发帖

gwd3-29,一个不同的思路.

Unlike the conviction held by many of her colleagues that genes were relatively simple and static, Barbara McClintock adhered to her own more complicated ideas about how genes might operate, and in 1983, at the age of 81, was awarded a Nobel Prize for her discovery that the genes in corn are capable of moving from one chromosomal site to another.

 

A.Unlike the conviction held by many of her colleagues that genes were relatively simple and static

 

B.Although many of her colleagues were of the conviction of genes being relatively simple and static

 

C.Contrary to many of her colleagues being convinced that genes were relatively simple and static

 

D.Even though many of her colleagues were convinced that genes were relatively simple and static

 

E.Even with many of her colleagues convinced of genes being relatively simple and static

 

没有搜到解释.答案是D ,但是我认为如果选D从句型分析,整体是个并列句,那么AND后面应加上主语SHE.原题中省略了主语,则应该理解为一个复合谓语,AND 前面不应为主从复合句,用短语结构为宜,所以选C.   至于BEING 结构, GMAT语法中也并非不可出现,尤其在非谓语结构中.

请NN指教....

收藏 分享

QUOTE:
以下是引用cheryong在2009-6-6 8:23:00的发言:

想问E为什么不对啊,with+n.+done,svo...是独立主格结构,貌似也没有错啊??

with独立主格结构与主句要形成紧密的逻辑联系哦,而且有一种从属的含义在里面

A comes in, with her eyes shut.

eyes是A的,闭眼的状态是A的。

GWD还是OG有一题,什么游客have seen monkey, with arms v.ed,arms是monkey的,with这个状态是在说monkey的。

这一题是要show一个contrast的意思,如果用with many of her colleagues, BM如何如何,就很奇怪了,同事们的状态成了BM的从属状态,同事们的动作从属于BM。

TOP

逻辑意思不对

咱们都是被xdf误导了 说什么什么看到哪个结构就一定错 
真正GMAT最关心的还是逻辑意思

准备3年内学会4种语言

TOP

想问E为什么不对啊,with+n.+done,svo...是独立主格结构,貌似也没有错啊??

TOP

 
QUOTE:
AND 前面不应为主从复合句,用短语结构为宜,

为什么呢?being正确地形式好像只有be being done和介词后被动

所以还是选D好

TOP

同意二楼的分析

TOP

没看懂楼主的意思,是说楼主认为  Even though sb. do sth. , A do sth. and do sth. 这种结构不对么?

 

这个题目的确应该选D的,或者说C有非常明显的缺陷

原题目中的意思是,尽管BM的大多数的同事都相信基因是相对简单而稳定的... BM坚持....,然后还获得了....

 

这里要指出的是在尽管这句话的结构里 相信基因相对简单稳定的 是 BM同事中的大部分,也就是说 1)存在一些同事也不信, 2)用于对比的应该是BM和上面说的那一大部分同事

 

C选项中 contrary to many of her colleagues being convinced that ..... (这里我们不讨论简洁的问题) being现在分词作定语修饰colleagus

所以意思是 对比 那些 认为基因相对简单的稳定的同事中 的 大部分, 那么这个意思在逻辑上是不对的 由于修饰语的位置不同,造成的意思的偏差

所以C是不对的

 

 

准备3年内学会4种语言

TOP

返回列表

站长推荐 关闭


美国top10 MBA VIP申请服务

自2003年开始提供 MBA 申请服务以来,保持着90% 以上的成功率,其中Top10 MBA服务成功率更是高达95%


查看