国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA

标题: P1 逻辑13题美国欧洲太阳能generator那道求助。 [打印本页]

作者: FGHYU19912301 时间: 2011-8-12 06:55 标题: P1 逻辑13题美国欧洲太阳能generator那道求助。

Which of the following most logically completes the argument?

United States manufacturers currently produce most of the world's solar-power generators--most of which are exported to Europe.However, European manufacturers are emerging and probably will ultimately capture much of the European market.The United States government is funding initiatives intended to encourage use of solar power within the United States.If these initiatives succeed in increasing the demand for solar-power generators in the United States, United States manufacturers will probably maintain significant production levels, since __________.

(A) some United States manufacturers have been substantially increasing their output over the last several years

(B) the efficiency of solar-power generators in converting energy from the Sun into electric power is not improving as fast as it once did

(C) just as European manufacturers enjoy certain competitive advantages in Europe, so do United States manufacturers in the United States

(D) European governments are currently undertaking initiatives to stimulate the use of solar power within Europe

(E) the current market for solar-power generators in the United States is very limited

答案选C。我做的时候选了E。
先去论坛搜了之前的讨论搞，似乎弄明白了一点，但还不能完全说服自己。

我现在的理解是这样的：

这道题不能多想，如果选E的话，那讲Euro那一段就没有用了。C选项就是和那一段类比得出的。而E是对原文most of which are exported to Europe的重复。

不知道对不对，求指教~~~

作者: alicejingli 时间: 2011-8-12 20:00

E talks about current, while whatever after "because" has to talk about the future or something has ramification in the future.

作者: FGHYU19912301 时间: 2011-8-16 06:30

谢谢~！

作者: chipmunk 时间: 2011-8-17 06:50

我是这样看的：如果要得出结论说美国制造商的生产规模，那么前提里也得有足够相关的说法，这推导才算成立。目前给出前提还没有这个意思，所以看完选项后，A和C讲的是美国制造商的生产，而C还提到了欧洲制造商的生产，也是题目里给过的说法，由此C是个更合理的选项。

作者: eeheaven 时间: 2011-8-17 20:26

我觉得楼主分析得很有道理啊，E选项需要加入主观信息，就是需要保证欧洲厂商不会侵占美国国内市场。而C最客观，与原文建立的联系最直接，因为原文已经说了most of the generators produced in the US are exported to Europe.说明美国国内市场还有很大的空间，而选项又说美国厂商在国内有竞争优势，也就印证了结论United States manufacturers will probably maintain significant production levels。

欢迎光临国际顶尖MBA申请交流平台--TOPWAY MBA (http://forum.topway.org/forum/)